Finding the Missing

New Videos Weekly

Follow along as a seasoned reporter and private investigator dive into cold cases, to help give families closure.

Season Two

Vanished In The Dead Of Night | The Search For Holly White

The bizarre disappearance of Holly Alcott White has left many in the small town of Taos, New Mexico desperate for answers.

In the early morning hours of May 6, 2016, Holly had plans to meet up with a friend for their daily walk. But when Holly didn’t show up, her friend made the decision to stop by her home. That’s where the friend found … Holly’s phone still plugged in, her purse toppled over on a table and her beloved pooch waiting to be let out.

Holly was nowhere to be found. Her car would be found within an hour, but that only left her family and friends with more unanswered questions. Days after her vanishing, a secret life would reveal itself. That has many now wondering … was there foul play involved in Holly’s mysterious disappearance?

Come with us as we unravel this puzzling case and go … Beyond The Case… to answer the question – Where is Holly?

If you, or someone you know, believe you have a tip that could help bring Holly White home email Beyond The Case at : You can remain anonymous.

You can also reach out to Private Investigator Elaine Graves at (575)-613-3415, or New Mexico State Police at (505) 454-5010.

Woman Claims To Be Missing Girl | Anthonette Cayedito | Part 3 | FULL EPISODE| (S2, E1)

This episode is sponsored by PremierX Pest Control. Anthonette Cayedito went missing when she was 9, in 1986, from Gallup, N.M. Her disappearance has haunted her younger sister, Sadie, who continues searching for answers. The recent discovery of an interview that the FBI conducted with Anthonette’s mother has fueled the belief that the young girl was given away and could be alive. Thirty seven years after she vanished in the middle of the night from the family’s Gallup home, a woman now believes she could be the missing sibling. Could she be Anthonette? Let’s go Beyond The Case…as the team travels to Texas and turns to DNA to find out the answer.

SEASON 2: Trailer

Beyond The Case is diving into new cases for Season 2! In this season, we are looking for a young mom who went missing when she was 4-months pregnant. We are also looking into the bizarre vanishing of a woman who was on the verge of major change in her life...did she jump or was there foul play involved in her disappearance? Beyond The Case is retracing the steps of a passionate detective who tried to solve the disappearance of a woman who went missing before she could get home to her daughter's birthday party. FIRST...we followed up on a major lead in the Anthonette Cayedito case that had the team packing their bags and heading to Texas. This episode is the first uploaded case for Season 2...check it out now! Get go Beyond The Case!

Season One

DISAPPEARED in the Desert: A Teen's Last Mission Of Faith
What happened to Jennifer Pentilla?

Jennifer Pentilla was on a mission to help others when she disappeared in the New Mexico desert in October of 1991. The then 18-year-old had left her home in Montana and planned to enter Mexico near California. That plan fell through, so she decided to bike from California, through Arizona and into New Mexico. The last phone call she made to her mom was in Deming, NM. Then she vanished without a trace. Decades later and the search continues. Did a change in plans lead to Jennifer's last mission...and was the teen being followed?

We dive into the case and uncover new startling details that have never been revealed.

If you have information to bring Jennifer home reach out to us at

Mom Mysteriously Vanishes:
Where is Alesha Brookshier?

It's been 14 years since Alesha Brookshier, a mom of two, disappeared from a small New Mexico town. The last person who says they saw her was the man she was living with. The couple had been legally divorced in 2002, but family members of the missing mom said they would routinely get back together.

The hours before Alesha Brookshier would vanish, she got into a heated argument with her on-again, off-again ex-husband. Her son witnessed it, creeping onto the roof of their home and listening to every word that was said. When the couple drove off, that would be the last time he or his sister would see their mom.

While her disappearance is already bizarre; there would be more strange things that would take place the months and years after she vanished. Come with us, as we go “Beyond The Case” and dive into this mystery that’s left Alesha’s sister with more questions than answers.

Disappeared In Darkness:
The Disappearance of Anthonette Cayedito

It’s been a decades-long nightmare for the sisters of Anthonette Cayedito. Anthonette,9, went missing April 6, 1986, while her family was sleeping in their Gallup home.

Her mother initially told police that she last saw Anthonette at 3am, Sunday morning, asleep. When the family woke up Anthonette was gone. According to FBI records, her mother’s story changed about 8 years after the girl’s disappearance.

This case has many twists and turns, but for the first time, you will hear a version of the story that Anthonette’s sister, Sadie, says was their life. And…we have documents in the police case file that support it.

Was Anthonette being watched by a stranger? Did Anthonette run away?...Or, was someone she knew somehow linked to her mysterious vanishing?

Come with us as we go…Beyond The Case!

Missing Cousins

Billy, 11, and Mary Lou, 9, were out riding their bicycles in September of 1979. Their typical day of play would turn into a decades-long nightmare for their family and friends, after the two cousins never returned home. There have been many theories of what could have happened to the children who lived in Albuquerque, N.M. But there is one question that remains the same … Where’s Billy and Mary Lou?

Get in Touch